Clinging To A Breakup I Didn’t See Coming

11 AUGUST 2024 | EMMA COLANGELO

 

His mouth made the shape “I don’t love you anymore,” but all I heard was a shrill ring reverberating through a void. Like the sound a hospital makes when a heart stops. The first step of grieving is denial, and I dove right in.

“I do not accept,” I argued. 

“That’s okay.” There was no argument. 

He got up to leave. I didn’t recognize him without his love for me. It used to fill his entire face. There were tiny wells of it in his dimples. I chased after him, hoping he had just concealed it too well, but I’d find the remnant glimmers if I looked more closely.  

“We can still be friends though, right? You can still stay for dinner. They are serving gyoza.”

I wasn’t ready to lose him in entirety. I’d take scraps. Breadcrumbs. His old t-shirts he forgot to ask me to return. Whatever he was willing to leave behind. I’d even take obligatory pity friendship, which I could tell by the reluctant apprehension in his nod was the only type he was willing to give. 

Photo credit Lilya Kunitskaya
We’d silently eat mediocre dining hall gyoza on the floor of my dorm room. My roommate would walk in. I'd cackle maniacally and say “we just broke up! No big deal! I’m fine!” – hoping it’d come across as blunt and endearing. Like Zooey Deschanel. It wouldn’t.

He’d unceremoniously leave. I’d stand in the doorway and watch him go like a girl in a romcom who’d get him back in the end. But then a girl who lived on my floor would walk by and ask me who the hot man was. That’s the moment it would hit me. He’d walk out that door to the arms of women. Other women. Women more beautiful than me. More interesting. Women more blunt and endearing like Zooey Deschanel. 

I’m not a girl in a romcom though. I’m just a person whose plot doesn’t revolve around another person. There would be other women. So many other women. He’d write the lyrics “I don’t love you anymore, and I’m headed for the door” a few months later about that very moment, and he’d perform them at my all women’s college student center while eye fucking my classmates. 

But there would be other women for me too. 

Women I’d fall in love with, yes. More importantly though, women who forced my blinds open and threw sundresses at me when I didn’t want to get out of bed. Women who made me playlists with “Gray or Blue” by Jaymay on them. Women who overanalyzed every tiny detail with me. Women who reminded me I would love again. Women who showed me I am resilient and reminded me who the fuck I was. 

And one day, many years later: my heart would break again, but it wouldn’t hurt as badly or endure for nearly as long. Not because it was less broken, but because I had already built the resilience. 

Resilience happens when we survive our feelings and prove to ourselves we can come out on the other side. I think about those moments of profound heartbreak with an unusual fondness, perhaps even a tinge of longing. Our first heartbreak marks the first occasion in adulthood where our inner child confronts the formidable prospect of surviving the loss of deeply attached love. That feeling we won’t survive a heartbreak is wired into our biological desire to survive. So we are left with no other choice but to survive on our own. We survive by taking that love and giving it to our passions, or to the people who force us out of bed and make us playlists. 
attachment dating

← Older Post Newer Post →

Why Playing Hard to Get is Actually Killing Your Love Life

Why Playing Hard to Get is Actually Killing Your Love Life

Modern dating is built on fear—of rejection, of being too much—but true connection comes not from playing it cool, but from showing up authentically, expressing...

Read more
Why Some Lovers Feel Like Home and Others Feel Like a Mistake

Why Some Lovers Feel Like Home and Others Feel Like a Mistake

Sex is a biological symphony of hormones, but chemistry defies science. Men crash into sleep, women bond through oxytocin, and attraction remains unpredictable—sometimes fueled by...

Read more
Out of Your Head and Into Your Body

Out of Your Head and Into Your Body

Intimacy, real intimacy, lives here—in the tension, the teasing, the maddening anticipation we often rush through. It’s not about perfection or performance. It’s in the...

Read more
Cleopatra: Our Eternal Muse of Mind, Body, and Ritual

Cleopatra: Our Eternal Muse of Mind, Body, and Ritual

To know Cleopatra is to understand mastery—a fusion of allure and intellect, where beauty and ritual were tools of both power and presence. Inspired by...

Read more
Moringa: The Miracle Tree

Moringa: The Miracle Tree

Revered for its ability to hydrate and heal, Moringa was a staple in ancient skincare and spiritual practices, embodying the essence of resilience and renewal.

Read more
January 2025 Horoscopes

January 2025 Horoscopes

There are many ways to ring in a new year, and we like to use these first few weeks to look forward. We collected these...

Read more

Explore Afterplay